Although I did not know who is John coy before, I can assert that he is a very success designer through seeing his portfolio. John gave us a lot of ideas and experiences that he gained from his personal occupational career. For example, as a designer, how to judge yourself is very important, because only you are the one who you mostly. In addition you also the one who know what you are good at and what your goal. When you see yourself clear, you will follow yourself directly to the success.
After the short dialogue with the students, John started his portfolio screen from a logo of Washington Mutual. I think that John put this logo at the first because he believed this is his most successful design artwork. Because working with a big corporation, like Washington Mutual, required a lot of skills for the designer. The designer must be very sensitive to feel and understanding the culture of the client, otherwise the designer may convey some wrong information that deviate to the corporation. Beside this, a good designer must be smart and negotiable, because to persuade a big corporation accept and adopt your design is a tough work.
I appreciate his achievement in his career that his told in his presentation. But I personal think he gave us less information about his artwork. For example, he only told us what his did before, but what I interested is how did he do it, and why did he do in that particular way.
Washington mutual was a nation wide bank and I can guarantee anybody know the logo of the bank. However only a few people know the meaning behind the logo. I suppose that if he can bring us some sketches of the logo that allow us to know how dose this idea originated, and I expect to know everything about the logo, including the typeface, the color, the counter line, the structure etc. I really wished that he could tell us the story of designing a logo from the beginning to the end, even some trivial detail such as how to fix the problem of the design when you negotiate with your client.
Maybe because of the he got to much information want to convey to us within 2 hours. He only told us some personal concept and his experience of operating a studio. I think his presentation is too general. I really expect to see a presentation that focus on design itself rather than telling a personal biography. I admit that John is a great designer, but as a educator, he should concern more about the what is the student really need. This quarter some student will graduate, they urge to find a job, so some encouragement remark is important for them. However the must realize that success is based on the ability, otherwise everything is empty talk.